GubernatorFan wrote:Interesting analysis, Craig. It certainly explains this from a marketing and financial point of view, upon which so much depends in practical terms. Which is not to say that it makes it right, in my opinion.
As for female Thor, you guys are absolutely right, that is an actual Marvel character, not something invented for the newest movie or a cosplay-type action figure line. But its origin still seems questionably derivative and subject to the kind of criticism raised by David. My problems with this are manifold, but a major one is the notion that, like James Bond, the position and identity of Thor could be filled by more than one individual. It is bad enough that Norse gods are in some sense mortal (and that is a quirk of Norse mythology, not of the Marvel universe).
If it can cheer you up, rumors are going strong about Tom Hardy being the next James Bond! That is a very good example anyway of what I find questionable in some "reboots/remakes". The 007 books depicted a very specific character, and while it can be modernized, I find it pretty childish to turn him into a woman instead of creating a new character... From a Alias to Atomic Blonde, there are plenty of examples of good female spy characters without having to "cancel" an iconic hero to make him fit some kind of political agenda. Tomb Raider's Lara Croft is a great character too, who doesn't need to have a hat and whip, neither to be named Dr Jones! To me it only proves a lack of understanding and work (I seriously hope this "cancel" everything that doesn't fit today's standards is gonna end soon)
Diana wrote: blackpool wrote:... I would have prefered to see new characters with new challenges and contemporary subjects, rather than transport heroes designed in the early 60's and force them into our 2000's society. Marvel used to be a fantastic idea and concepts factory, so it's a bit disappointing from them to my eyes
I honestly hope they will continue to bring back and reinvent these characters, because they already have such a vast catalogue of stories to draw from. Not all good, but hindsight is always 20/20, and they can benefit from that when reinventing/modernizing these characters. It would be a crying shame to let all those stories fade away.
I totally agree those Marvel stories and characters shouldn't be left behind, I believe most of them could be sent to screen or reread leaving them in their original context (not everything has to be modern and contemporary ) but it's a complicated work to reboot them correctly, fully understanding the why and when they were created.
They all reflect a time and context, very often political, and this is what makes them difficult to just bring back. A good example is captain America, they did just fine modernizing the character, passing his shield to the younger generation, yet keeping his background of american soldier from world war 2, and its unique context of the western world being a symbol of freedom fighting fachism. Imagine a captain america who's origin would be the questionable war in Vietnam, or the second war in Irak... The meaning would be very controversial, the symbol totally different...
I'd really prefer that they keep creating original characters like they used to for over 50 years, or work more on the many undevelopped characters they have, instead of rebooting everything to please the latest audience. The guardians of the galaxy, Spawn, the wildcats, Fathom, Gen13, there are tons of examples of good comics creations from the last 20-30 years, totally independent from the iconic captain america, iron man or spiderman... Why stop being creative now?
As another example, some of you may have heard about the recent controversy as an old character will appear in the next Captain America. A female hero named "Sabra", israeli soldier turning into a supes at night to fight palestinians. I'm very sceptical of the outcome honestly (it was already a hazardous concept in the 70's to my eyes, but much more understandable at the time of the Kippour war between Israel and a league of Arab countries led by Egypt and Syria)