GeeWillikers wrote: MeMyself&I wrote:The feet options are for sure the best part of this though. Their new floppy foot design is somehow worse than the old one I think, so removable feet as an option is a major upgrade!!
I dunno about that now, to be honest. Of course I'll never buy them over detachable-foot models without a
massive improvement for purely practical reasons, but the recent floppies
do actually have side-to-side ankle rotation, which the old seamless feet never did (I discovered this feature completely by accident some weeks after purchase of an S42). And while they're larger and have lost that nice feminine 'arch', they
are more realistically-designed. The only real - but suitably large - problem with them is that the hard (I assume) plastic 'foot' inside/under the TPE doesn't extend far enough into the 'skin' of the foot to stabilise them enough so that they can stand.
After hating them to start with, I've grown to accept that for some purposes, while not exactly preferable, they're actually OK.
Oh, I agree with the points you made about the good parts of them (ironically, I found out about the rotating ankles the exact same way you did with my S42, completely by accident). And they are, to a point, better in some use cases.
I do respectfully stand behind my point though in that where these feet go wrong, they do so quite well. As you pointed out, the support for the foot itself is minimal. I nearly ruined my S42 checking out some stockings for it. Stretch fabric is very forgiving, but it had some strong words for me during that process. It has everything to do with the fact it
bends in the middle of the foot. Like, why? What possessed you to design it this way TBL? A little longer, not enough even to make it stand, but just a little longer so it didn't bend
there and we'd be cool. I love the S42, but that is one area I do not like.
I do think the S34 is better in this regard, as it is just physically smaller, but at the same time I feared to do anything for the same reasons. I unfortunately don't have my S34 anymore, nor did I for very long. Pretty sure BBTS got a bad batch, as I went through 2 of them in the course of 2-3 weeks only to have a wide range of major issues. BBTS was great about it as always, but I had plans for a character that got sidelined hard because of it. I digress though.
Either way, they do have their uses as you said GW, I do agree. And I don't
hate them, I just wish that I would have the same experience with them that I have had with the old (which has, by and large, been perfectly fine. Only one issue in 5 S07Cs).